| Category |
Winner, Sport |
| Spring Newcomer of the Year |
Riley Stiles, Softball |
| Spring Athlete of the Year |
Emmie Nyen, Softball |
| Outstanding Team Community Service |
Men's Basketball, Men's Lacrosse |
| Upset Victory |
Men's Tennis at Oberlin |
| Individual Record-Setting Performance (Male) |
Tyler Wengronowitz, Men's Golf |
| Individual Record-Setting Performance (Female) |
Kaia Mismash, Softball |
| Forester Game Plan Career Catalyst Award |
Ian VIllardi, Men's Tennis |
| FCA Roaring Lambs Award |
Will Brown, Men's Hockey |
| Fall Newcomer of the Year |
James Jordan, Football |
| Fall Athlete of the Year |
Izzy DeStefano, Women's Soccer |
| Student Worker of the Year |
John Niccoli |
| Individual Championship Performance (Male) |
Ollie Francis, Men's Track & Field |
| Individual Championship Performance (Female) |
Audrey Kilmer, Women's Swimming & Diving |
| Individual Clutch Performance |
Gabrielle Krebs, Women's Golf |
| Team Social Media of the Year |
Women's Volleyball |
| Winter Newcomer of the Year |
Lily Peterfeso, Women's Hockey |
| Winter Athlete of the Year |
Isabella Rosenbergas, Women's Swimming & Diving |
| Inspirational Leader of the Year (Female) |
Anika Kinnear, Women's Basketball |
| Inspirational Leader of the Year (Male) |
Alex Brown, Men's Basketball |
| Unsung Hero |
Vinny Colasacco, Football |
| Team Record-Setting Performance |
Women's Soccer |
| Team Championship Performance |
Women's Lacrosse |
| Team Clutch Performance |
Women's Tennis |
| Jackie Slaats Commitment to Excellence Award |
Meredith Cavaleri |
| Forester Career Award (Female) |
Anna Hoffman, Women's Soccer |
| Forester Career Award (Male) |
Conor Murphy, Men's Lacrosse |
